Buying an xTool S1? The Answer Depends on What You're Cutting
Why There's No Single "Right" Answer
I've been running a laser engraving shop since 2019. Over that time, I've made — and documented — roughly a dozen significant purchasing mistakes totaling somewhere around $2,400 in wasted budget. In 2021, I bought about $400 worth of S1 accessories I ended up using twice.
So when someone asks "Is the xTool S1 worth it?" or more specifically "Can you laser engrave silicone?" or "Will it cut metal?" — the honest answer is: it depends on which of three buyers you are.
Here's how I've come to categorize the people who ask me about this machine:
- The hobbyist or side-hustler — mostly wood, leather, maybe some acrylic, trying to make a little money on the side
- The shop or small business — wants to add laser capability to an existing production workflow
- The specific-material seeker — has a particular need: metal, silicone, glass, and wants to know if this machine will do it
Each scenario has a fundamentally different cost calculus. Let me break them down.
Scenario 1: The Hobbyist or Side-Hustler
If you're engraving wood signs, leather goods, and the occasional acrylic piece for an Etsy shop, the xTool S1 is a solid machine. The 40W module will cut 3/4-inch pine all day — that's plenty for most craft-level production.
Here's the total cost of ownership trap most first-time buyers miss: they look at the base machine price and forget everything else. The rotary attachment? Roughly $200-300. Air assist? Another $100. Honeycomb bed? Another $100. Consumables (wood blanks, leather scraps, acrylic sheets) — you're looking at $200-400 before you sell anything. And the learning curve? I spent roughly three weeks, evenings and weekends, before I felt genuinely comfortable with settings.
My actual first-year cost was about 1.7x the sticker price of the machine. Not trying to scare you — just keep expectations realistic.
Here's something vendors won't tell you: the accessories are where the margin lives. Dealers often make more profit from three accessory sales than from one machine sale. So expect the sales rep to push every add-on in the catalog. My advice? Get the machine with the module you need. Add accessories only when you've got a specific order that demands one.
The risk-reward math: skip the rotary and you save $250, but you lose the ability to do cylindrical products — tumblers, glasses, pens. For a side hustle, that's probably leaving money on the table. For a pure hobbyist, it's fine.
If you take away one thing: buy the base machine first. Add accessories when an actual paying job requires one. This worked for us, but our situation was a steady mid-volume shop with predictable order patterns. If you're buying purely for occasional personal projects, the calculus might be completely different — you might not need the 40W module at all.
Scenario 2: The Metal-Focused Buyer — A Reality Check
This is where the biggest misconception lives.
Can the xTool S1 engrave metal? Yes — on stainless steel, aluminum, and some coated surfaces, at the marking level. Can it cut metal? Not in any practical production sense. It'll burn through 1mm thin sheet metal if you're patient and the stars align, but the edge quality won't match what a CO₂ or fiber laser delivers.
What most people don't realize is that "metal cutting" in the diode laser world really means surface marking on specific metals with specific coatings — not through-cutting. If your primary need is metal workflow — even light production cutting on mild steel or aluminum — a fiber laser or CNC mill will serve you far better. The TCO calculation with the S1 in a metal production context simply doesn't work, because you multiply your processing time by every pass.
Real talk: if more than 30% of your jobs involve cutting metal, you're buying the wrong machine. Period. No amount of 40W output changes the underlying physics of diode wavelength and metal absorption.
Where the S1 does make sense for metal: marking logos on metal parts, occasional thin-sheet work, and mixed-material projects where metal is maybe 10-15% of your output. But don't buy it expecting a poor-man's plasma cutter.
The cost decision here is tricky: if metal is truly occasional, adding a small fiber laser module (around $3,000-4,000 for an entry-level unit) alongside the S1 might actually give you a better overall TCO than buying one premium single-purpose machine. But if metal is only 5% of your work, that's overkill — just mark the metal and move on.
I've second-guessed this one myself. Even after settling on the S1 for our non-metal work, I kept wondering: what if I should've put that budget toward a fiber unit instead? The answer ended up being no — our material mix was 75% wood and leather — but until I actually ran the numbers, I wasn't sure.
Scenario 3: The Silicone (and Soft Material) Question
Can you laser engrave silicone? Technically, yes. Practically, I'd push you in another direction. Three reasons:
One: the fumes. Silicone produces some nasty off-gassing when laser-cut. You want active ventilation and ideally a respirator. The ANSI Z136 laser safety standard covers beam containment and eyewear, but silicone isn't on most vendor material safety matrices — which should tell you something. I made the mistake of running a batch without adequate airflow in early 2022. Two days of coughing and a headache that wouldn't quit. Do not recommend.
Two: the finish. Laser engraving on silicone creates a rough, charred surface that's almost impossible to clean up nicely. The color is inconsistent — sometimes dark brown, sometimes uneven black. The edge feels like burnt rubber.
Three: the speed. Silicone engraves slowly because you need low power and multiple passes to avoid melting. I tested 20 custom silicone wristbands — single side, simple logo. It took over two hours, and the results were inconsistent across the batch.
Here's the counterintuitive advice: for silicone, casting or pad-printing often beats laser engraving on both quality and total cost — including the time you'd burn on trial-and-error settings. If you absolutely must laser silicone, keep expectations low: single-side, small area, and accept some charring.
Same logic applies to most rubber compounds: test on scrap first, and always ventilate like your lungs depend on it.
How to Figure Out Which Scenario You're In
Run this quick self-check:
- If wood, leather, and acrylic make up 80% or more of your material plans → Scenario 1. Buy the base machine, add accessories as orders demand.
- If cutting or engraving metal is 20% or more of your workload → Scenario 2. Seriously price out fiber laser or CNC options before committing.
- If silicone, rubber, or soft PVC appear in your material mix → Scenario 3. Test scrap samples first, and have a backup plan.
And here's the TCO calculation I wish I'd run earlier: take the machine price, add every accessory you think you need, add three months of consumables, add the hourly rate of your time for learning, plus your expected waste rate in year one. If you're a side-hustler, add a better ventilation setup or a dedicated workbench. If that total is more than twice what you expect to earn in your first year of production — wait. Re-run the math.
I didn't do this in 2021, and I ended up with $400 in accessories sitting in a basement cabinet for a year. Wouldn't wish that on anyone. Hopefully this saves you at least one avoidable mistake.